A few glaring errors remained. In the editorial, Mt Arapiles was referred to as "the Arapiles" - if ever you needed a sign that the editor wasn't a climber, this is it. Do you call it the Everest? The Kosciusko? Also, what kind of editor allows the sentence "Next time your going climbing..." to go to print?
I've been reading over some older copies of Rock edited by Baxter, Megan and Ross recently, and he's got a long, long way to get even close to the quality they produced. |