You guys are the odd ones out ... Geoff, Maureen, Ray and a cast of thousands were there for about the 3rd time on Friday having a great time and being really positive about all the routes. Lou and Kane have been back a couple of times. Caela. Kate. Zoe. Kieran. Noddy turned up and promptly did another new route. Did you do Wild Mtn Thyme and Babylon? They are really nice. Pork Chop and Pet Parsley have been getting good feedback. Maybe you should look at it like Preludes Wall. How often would you go to Preludes Wall? Go there when you have someone you need to climb 15-18 with and see how it goes down then. Same with Shiralee Wall.
You are also the only person who didn't like Stinky Project! Esther, Bec, Douglas and I all liked it. You only had 1 run on it and chucked a tanty! It might be short but it has sustained funky moves on nice rock.
Remember that 2 star classic at Barbican Rocks? How good do FNR Garden Wall look in comparison:)?